An Antidote for Hope-ium: Mindfulness
The pattern of struggle was well-established: Sarah would voice a concern and Troy would blow up, yell, or give her the silent treatment until she acknowledged the problem was hers alone. Troy would later say, he knew he was out-of-control, but she was the one who pushed his buttons. Sarah didn’t want to face how bad the relationship had gotten, so she convinced herself (and it didn’t take much convincing) that she could manage Troy’s outbursts better next time. She could be more accommodating. With that hope, she carried on.
Patrick Doyle[i], a therapist, coined the term “hope-ium” to describe when a person denies harmful behavior and instead looks for small moments or experiences that bolster the false hope that they are not being harmed or that things will magically change. Dr. Doyle asks people to consider the connection between hope and a painkiller. If painkillers are used for a short time to overcome a difficult event (like surgery) that’s an appropriate and necessary use. However, painkillers can become problematic when they are relied upon, and the person is dependent. In this case, painkillers prohibit growth, healing, or resolution. Hope can be like a drug—use it appropriately and it’s a powerful tool for recovery. Overuse it and it impedes growth, autonomy, and may even encourage unhealthy tolerance to abusive behavior.
Is This a Difficult or Destructive Relationship?
For some people it’s hard to distinguish between what’s just a difficult relationship and what is destructive or abusive. Emotional abuse seems vague to some people. Here are some important warning signs for emotional abuse:
You feel crazy or like you’re never heard
You are always to blame
Your partner tries to isolate you and control who you talk to
Problems never resolve and your feelings are minimized
If any of these are your experience, consider seeing a therapist who specializes in destructive relationships.
Using Hope-ium to Avoid
Using hope to avoid the reality of the destructive behavior is not helpful or healthy. For hope to be helpful, both partners must act on what is hoped for. Hope is hard won, not an ignorance to reality.
Recent research suggests that there is a close connection between false hope and ignorance.[ii]When a person chooses to ignore or pretend that the behavior isn‘t problematic, that‘s hope-ium. Instead of dealing with the immediate issue, bad behaviors become more entrenched and wounds festers. Hope is justified only if it is “realistic.” That is when hope is based on good judgement and the likelihood of performance. But when patterns continually indicate poor behavior, hope is not warranted. When a person ignores regular poor behavior to maintain hope, they are using hope-ium—or a false hope that keeps them stuck in a destructive pattern. To avoid hope-ium—Don’t distort reality.
Use Mindfulness Not Hope-ium
Mindfulness is a practice of slowing down thoughts and focusing on breath. It sounds simple and it is—but it takes practice.[iii]Although mindfulness is associated with happiness, productivity,[iv]satisfaction in relationships, and lower stress,[v]
it achieves these positive outcomes not through fanciful denial or avoidance. Mindfulness as a practice requires a constant attunement with the reality of the present and an acceptance of what can and cannot be done. Hope-ium is simply an avoidance tactic or an unwillingness to address the problematic realities of the relationship.
Mindfulness encourages an opposite approach. Instead of avoidance, sit with the reality of the destructive behavior. Acceptance means no longer resisting or denying what is. It is not approval of the bad behavior.[vi]An accepting person is not condoning, agreeing with, or sanctioning the bad behavior. Acceptance is the first step to sorting through the issues of the relationship. If a partner is willing, talk through the issues and frankly discuss healthy boundaries. If a partner is not open to authentically addressing the destructive behaviors (which likely includes counseling) then mindfully consider what steps need to be taken to create a healthier environment. This may require permanent separation from the destructive environment.
Here is one way to practice mindfulness instead of hope-ium.
When you experience problematic behaviors:
Ask yourself: How do I feel in my body? Connect with your body.
See if you can locate a place where your feelings are most noticeable. You may notice a concentration of emotion in your head or face, your heart, or a weight on your shoulders, or an ache in your belly.
Mentally “breathe” into that location (In other words, visualize that you are infusing fresh air). Then touch it warmly with your hand.
Let go of the need to make the feeling go away. Let it be there moment by moment and notice what it does or how it feels. Accept this moment, even if it is filled with sorrow. This moment is precious and can teach you.
Hope-ium is a druglike response to avoid the hard realities of a problematic relationship. Mindfulness is acceptance and action to address the harm, the wounded feelings, and gain perspective on how to move forward.
[ii]Musschenga, B. (2019, July). Is there a problem with false hope?. In The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine (Vol. 44, No. 4, pp. 423-441). US: Oxford University Press.
[iii]Leavitt, C. E., Butzer, B., Clarke, R. W., & Dvorakova, K. (2021). Intentional solitude and mindfulness: The benefits of being alone. The handbook of solitude: Psychological perspectives on social isolation, social withdrawal, and being alone, 340-350.
[iv]Coo, C., & Salanova, M. (2018). Mindfulness can make you happy-and-productive: A mindfulness controlled trial and its effects on happiness, work engagement and performance. Journal of Happiness Studies, 19, 1691-1711.
[v]Barnes, S., Brown, K. W., Krusemark, E., Campbell, W. K., & Rogge, R. D. (2007). The role of mindfulness in romantic relationship satisfaction and responses to relationship stress. Journal of marital and family therapy, 33(4), 482-500.
